Quick Answer: Yes, you can sue the city, county, or the South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) for a pothole accident, but only under the South Carolina Tort Claims Act (S.C. Code § 15-78-10 et seq.). You must prove the government entity knew, or should have known, about the pothole and failed to fix it within a reasonable time. You have just one year to file a written notice of claim and two years to file a lawsuit, and recovery is capped at $300,000 per person. Missing these deadlines can end your case before it starts, so talk to an attorney immediately.
Hitting a pothole at 45 miles per hour can blow a tire, bend a rim, total a suspension, or send a car into oncoming traffic. For motorcyclists, cyclists, and pedestrians, a bad pothole can mean broken bones, a concussion, or worse. If that happened to you on a South Carolina road, you are probably asking one question: can you actually make the government pay for it?
The answer is yes, but suing a city, county, or state agency in South Carolina is nothing like suing another driver. Government entities are shielded by sovereign immunity, and the narrow exception that lets you sue comes with tight deadlines, damage caps, and a heavier burden of proof than an ordinary car accident claim. Here is what South Carolina law actually requires, and why the sooner you call a lawyer, the better your odds of recovering what you deserve.
Key Takeaways
- South Carolina law allows lawsuits against government entities for pothole and road defect accidents under the South Carolina Tort Claims Act, but sovereign immunity still applies to most situations.
- You must prove the responsible government entity had actual or constructive notice of the pothole and failed to repair it within a reasonable time. A pothole that appeared the same day is much harder to win than one that had been reported for months.
- You have one year to file a written notice of claim and two years total to file a lawsuit. Waiting even a few extra weeks can hurt your case.
- Recovery against the government is capped at $300,000 per person and $600,000 per single occurrence, and punitive damages are not allowed.
- Figuring out whether the city, the county, or SCDOT maintained the road is often the hardest part of the case, and filing against the wrong entity can cost you your claim.
- If the pothole was only one factor in your crash, such as a driver who swerved into your lane trying to avoid it, you may have additional claims against a private party as well.
- The Thumbs Up Guys handle pothole and road defect claims on a contingency basis. You pay nothing unless we win.
For a free legal consultation, call (843) 380-8350
Can You Sue the City for a Pothole Accident in South Carolina?
In general, yes. Historically, South Carolina cities, counties, and the state itself could not be sued at all under a doctrine called sovereign immunity. That changed in 1986 when the state legislature passed the South Carolina Tort Claims Act, which carved out a limited path for injured people to hold government entities accountable for negligence, including negligent road maintenance.
That means a pothole accident claim against the government is treated very differently from a claim against a careless driver or a private business. You are not simply proving that a hazard existed and that it hurt you. You have to prove three things:
- A government entity owned or maintained the road where the pothole was located.
- That entity knew, or reasonably should have known, about the pothole and had a fair opportunity to fix it.
- The pothole caused or substantially contributed to your accident and injuries.
Pothole cases can arise from many types of collisions, including:
- A car accident where a driver lost control after hitting a pothole, blew a tire, or suffered a broken axle
- A motorcycle accident where a rider was thrown after hitting a hidden or deep pothole
- A bicycle accident where a cyclist crashed swerving around, or riding into, a pothole
- A pedestrian accident where someone tripped in a pothole or crumbling section of road or sidewalk
- A multi-vehicle crash where one driver hit a pothole and lost control into another lane
Regardless of the type of vehicle or accident involved, the legal framework is the same: the South Carolina Tort Claims Act, not an ordinary negligence lawsuit, governs your right to recover.
Who Is Actually Responsible for the Road?
Before you can sue anyone, you have to figure out exactly who was responsible for maintaining the stretch of road where you were hurt. This sounds simple, but in South Carolina it frequently is not, and getting it wrong can cost you your entire claim.
Road maintenance responsibility in South Carolina generally falls into one of three buckets:
- The South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT), which maintains the vast majority of state highways and numbered routes
- County government, which maintains many rural and unincorporated roads
- City or municipal government, which maintains streets within city limits
A single road can even change jurisdiction as it crosses from unincorporated county land into a city, or where a state highway becomes a city-maintained street. Some roads near shopping centers, apartment complexes, or private developments may not be publicly maintained at all, in which case a private property owner, rather than the government, could be the correct party to pursue.
Because notice deadlines run separately for each entity, and because filing against the wrong one does not pause your clock, identifying the correct government entity as early as possible is one of the single most important steps in a pothole case. An attorney can pull maintenance records, easement agreements, and jurisdictional maps to confirm exactly who is responsible before your deadline runs.
Click to contact our personal injury lawyers today
The South Carolina Tort Claims Act: How Suing the Government Works
The South Carolina Tort Claims Act (S.C. Code § 15-78-10, et seq.) is the only way to sue a government entity over a road defect injury in South Carolina. It applies to the state, SCDOT, counties, cities, and other political subdivisions, along with their employees acting within the scope of their duties.
The Act is what lawyers call a limited waiver of sovereign immunity. It does not open the door to every kind of claim. Several important rules make government road cases fundamentally different from a claim against a private driver or business:
The government is not automatically liable just because a hazard existed. Property owners generally have a duty to maintain safe conditions, but under the Tort Claims Act, a government entity is only liable for a road hazard if it had notice of the specific defect and a reasonable opportunity to fix it.
Discretionary decisions are often protected. Courts have found that some decisions about which roads to prioritize for repair, and how public resources are allocated, are discretionary governmental functions that remain immune from suit even under the Tort Claims Act. This is a frequent battleground in road defect litigation and one reason these cases benefit from experienced legal representation.
The Act is your exclusive remedy. You cannot bring an ordinary negligence lawsuit against a city or county for a road hazard. Every claim must be structured to meet the Tort Claims Act’s specific requirements, filed within its shorter deadlines, and litigated within its damage limits.
No punitive damages. Because the government has not fully waived its immunity, punitive damages are not available in these cases, no matter how careless the entity’s conduct was.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
Proving the City Knew About the Pothole
This is usually the make-or-break element of a South Carolina pothole case. The law requires proof of actual notice (someone at the agency already knew about the pothole, often through a prior complaint, work order, or accident report) or constructive notice (the pothole had existed long enough, and was obvious enough, that the responsible agency should have discovered and repaired it through routine inspection).
A pothole that formed overnight, or that was reported and repaired within a reasonable window, is much harder to hold the government liable for. A pothole that had been growing for months, generated multiple 311 complaints or prior accident reports, or sat unrepaired well past the agency’s own maintenance schedule, is a much stronger case.
Evidence that helps establish notice and causation includes:
- Prior complaints or 311/service requests filed with the city, county, or SCDOT about that specific location
- Records of previous accidents or vehicle damage claims at the same pothole
- Photos and videos of the pothole, ideally showing its size, depth, and how long it had clearly been present
- Maintenance and repair logs for that stretch of road
- Traffic or dashcam footage of your own accident
- Eyewitness statements
- Expert analysis reconstructing how the pothole caused your crash
Much of this evidence, particularly internal complaint logs and inspection records, is not something you can easily obtain on your own. An attorney can send preservation letters and use formal discovery tools to secure this evidence before it is lost, overwritten, or destroyed.
Click to contact our personal injury lawyers today
Deadlines That Can Kill Your Claim
Suing the government in South Carolina runs on a much shorter clock than a typical personal injury case, and missing it is one of the most common ways valid pothole claims are lost.
One year to file a verified claim for damages. Under S.C. Code § 15-78-80(d), you must submit a written, verified notice of your claim to the responsible government entity within one year of the date the loss occurred or reasonably should have been discovered.
A mandatory waiting period. Once your claim is filed, South Carolina law generally requires you to wait 180 days, or until the agency formally denies your claim, whichever happens first, before you can file a lawsuit.
Two years, sometimes extended to three, to file suit. The standard statute of limitations under the Tort Claims Act is two years from the date of the incident, found at S.C. Code § 15-78-110. Filing a proper verified claim within the first year can extend that window to three years, but only if the notice requirements were satisfied correctly.
Compare that to an ordinary personal injury claim against a private driver in South Carolina, where you typically have three full years to file suit with no separate notice requirement at all. The compressed timeline for government claims is intentional, and courts apply it strictly. Waiting to “see how you feel” or trying to negotiate with an agency’s claims department on your own before involving a lawyer can quietly cost you your entire case.
How Much Can You Recover From the Government?
Even a strong pothole case against the government comes with financial limits that would not apply if you were suing a private party. South Carolina law caps recovery against a government entity at $300,000 per person and $600,000 total per single occurrence, regardless of how severe the injuries are or how many people were hurt. These caps have remained unchanged since 1997 and are not adjusted for inflation.
Within those limits, compensable damages in a South Carolina pothole case can include:
- Medical expenses, including emergency treatment, surgery, physical therapy, and anticipated future care
- Lost wages and diminished earning capacity
- Pain and suffering
- Property damage, including vehicle repair or replacement
- Loss of enjoyment of life for permanent or long-term injuries
- Wrongful death damages for surviving family members, in fatal pothole accident cases
Punitive damages are never available against a government entity under the Tort Claims Act. If your damages are likely to exceed the applicable cap, or if a private party shares some responsibility for your accident, identifying every available source of recovery becomes especially important, which brings us to the next section.
What If the Pothole Was Only Part of the Problem?
Many pothole accidents are not purely “government versus driver.” Often, a private party contributed to the crash as well, and pursuing that party’s insurance can matter a great deal, particularly given how low the government’s damage caps are.
Common examples include:
- A driver who swerved to avoid a pothole and struck your vehicle
- A defective tire, wheel, or suspension component that failed when it hit the pothole, giving rise to a separate product liability claim against a manufacturer
- A private commercial property owner whose entrance road or parking lot, rather than a public street, contained the hazard
- A construction or utility contractor whose work created or worsened the road defect
South Carolina also follows a modified comparative negligence rule, meaning your own compensation can be reduced by your percentage of fault, and barred entirely if you are found more than 50% at fault. If you were, for example, driving distracted or well over the speed limit when you hit the pothole, the government or its insurer will likely raise that as a defense. An attorney can evaluate how comparative fault applies to your specific facts and identify every liable party so you are not left relying solely on a capped government claim.
What to Do Right After a Pothole Accident
What you do in the hours and days after a pothole accident can determine whether you have a winning claim at all.
1. Seek medical attention immediately, even if you feel only mildly injured. Some injuries, including concussions and soft tissue damage, are not obvious right away, and prompt treatment creates a medical record tied to the date of your accident.
2. Call the police and get an accident report. An official report documents the time, location, and circumstances of the crash, and often notes visible road conditions.
3. Photograph and video the pothole immediately, including its size, depth, and location, before the road is repaired or repaved. Once a pothole is fixed, this evidence can disappear within days.
4. Identify and photograph any prior repair patches, cones, warning signs, or lack thereof, which can help establish whether the agency knew about the hazard.
5. Get contact information from any witnesses, including other drivers who may have seen the pothole or experienced problems at the same location.
6. Report the pothole formally to the city, county, or SCDOT, and keep a copy of your complaint and any confirmation number. This creates an official record and may reveal whether others reported the same hazard previously. Report here.
7. Do not accept a quick settlement or sign anything from a government claims adjuster before speaking with an attorney. Government entities know their damage caps limit their exposure, and they often move quickly to close out claims for far less than they are worth.
8. Call the Thumbs Up Guys as soon as possible. Because notice deadlines for government claims are so much shorter than ordinary accident claims, the sooner an attorney is involved, the more evidence can be preserved and the stronger your case will be.
How a South Carolina Pothole Accident Lawyer Can Help
Pothole and road hazard cases against the government are some of the most procedurally demanding claims in South Carolina personal injury law. A single missed deadline, or a claim filed against the wrong government entity, can end your case regardless of how clearly the pothole caused your injuries.
When you work with the attorneys at The Thumbs Up Guys, we will:
- Identify the correct responsible party, whether that is SCDOT, a county, a municipality, or a private landowner, before your notice deadline runs
- Investigate immediately, gathering prior complaint records, maintenance logs, traffic camera footage, and witness statements before evidence disappears
- File all required notices and claims correctly and on time, protecting your right to sue if the claim is not resolved
- Build the strongest possible case for notice, showing the government knew or should have known about the hazard
- Pursue every available source of compensation, including any private parties who may share responsibility, not just the capped government claim
- Negotiate aggressively with government claims adjusters and litigate your case in court if a fair settlement is not offered
We handle pothole and road hazard cases on a contingency fee basis. That means there are no upfront costs, and you pay nothing unless we win.
If a pothole caused your accident anywhere in South Carolina, do not wait. The notice deadline for government claims is far shorter than most people realize, and evidence at the accident scene can vanish as soon as road crews make repairs. Click here for a free case review.
Call or text (843) 380-8350 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form
