Does sharing fault in a motorcycle accident mean you lose your right to compensation entirely? Under South Carolina law, the answer is no. Partial fault reduces but does not eliminate your ability to recover damages, as long as you were not more than 50% responsible for causing the accident.
Understanding how South Carolina’s comparative negligence law works can help protect your rights when insurance companies attempt to shift blame onto you. The Thumbs Up Guys help Charleston motorcyclists challenge inflated fault percentages and recover fair compensation even when they share some responsibility for their accidents.
Key Takeaways for Partial Fault Motorcycle Accidents
- You may recover compensation if you’re 50% or less at fault; above 50% bars all recovery.
- Your compensation gets reduced by your fault percentage under South Carolina law.
- Insurers may push higher rider fault percentages to reduce payouts.
- Minor violations don’t automatically make you majority at fault.
- Traffic citations provide one piece of evidence but don’t determine civil fault.
For a free legal consultation, call (843) 380-8350
Understanding South Carolina’s Comparative Negligence Law
South Carolina follows modified comparative negligence rules under SC Code § 15-38-15. This law allows you to recover compensation even when you share responsibility for an accident, with two important limitations.
First, you cannot recover any compensation if you were more than 50% at fault. This creates a threshold where crossing the halfway point bars all recovery. Second, your compensation is reduced by the percentage of fault you have. If you were 20% responsible, your damages decrease by 20%.
The 51% Bar Rule Explained
The 51% bar means fault determination becomes the critical battleground in many motorcycle accident claims. Insurance companies understand this threshold and sometimes try to assign motorcyclists 51% or more fault to eliminate liability entirely.
A jury or judge determines fault percentages in disputed cases, not insurance adjusters. Insurance companies make fault assessments during settlement negotiations, but these assessments carry no legal weight. You maintain the right to challenge any fault determination you believe unfairly assigns you majority responsibility.
How Fault Percentages Affect Your Compensation
Fault percentages directly reduce your compensation dollar-for-dollar. Consider a Charleston motorcycle accident with $100,000 in total damages from medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and motorcycle repairs.
If you were 10% at fault, you recover $90,000. If you were 30% at fault, you recover $70,000. If you were 49% at fault, you still recover $51,000. But if fault reaches 51%, you recover nothing.
These stakes make fighting inflated fault percentages critical. The Thumbs Up Guys challenge insurance company fault assessments with evidence showing the other driver’s violations contributed more significantly to your accident.
Common Scenarios Where Charleston Motorcyclists Share Fault
Certain traffic situations create scenarios where the motorcyclist and the other driver share responsibility. Understanding these scenarios helps you recognize when insurance companies fairly assess fault versus unfairly inflate your percentage.
Following Too Closely in Charleston Traffic
Following distance violations occur frequently in Charleston’s congested traffic on Highway 17, the James Island Connector, and downtown streets. Leaving several seconds of following distance improves reaction time in Charleston’s stop-and-go corridors.
When a driver ahead stops suddenly without signaling and you rear-end them while following closely, you may share some fault for the insufficient following distance. However, the other driver may bear greater responsibility for stopping without warning. Fault could land around one-third versus two-thirds in a scenario like this, depending on the evidence.
In many claims, insurance adjusters argue for majority fault to the rear vehicle in any rear-end collision. We challenge this assumption by proving that the front driver’s actions violated traffic laws and contributed more significantly to causing the crash.
Speed-Related Accidents on Highway 17 and Charleston Roads
Speed-related accidents create fault-sharing scenarios if motorcyclists exceeded the posted limit but other drivers committed more serious violations. Consider a rider traveling 40 mph in a 35 mph zone when a driver turns left across their path without yielding.
The rider shares fault for exceeding the speed limit by 5 mph. However, the driver who failed to yield right-of-way to oncoming traffic committed the primary violation that caused the collision. A small speed variance may contribute a smaller share of fault when the primary violation is failure to yield.
Insurance companies often use accident reconstruction to estimate motorcycle speed, then push those estimates higher to shift greater fault onto the rider. We counter with our own reconstruction experts who examine skid marks, debris fields, and vehicle damage to provide accurate speed analysis.
Lane Change and Positioning Issues
Lane change accidents happen throughout Charleston when drivers merge without checking blind spots. Motorcyclists sometimes share fault if they changed lanes without full signals while riding near other vehicles.
If you changed lanes with incomplete signaling when another driver also merged into the same space without checking mirrors, both parties may share fault. However, the driver who failed to check blind spots before merging often bears greater responsibility.
Riding in blind spots is legal but creates dangerous situations. Insurance adjusters sometimes argue that legal positioning in a blind spot constitutes negligent riding. We counter that drivers have the legal duty to check blind spots before merging, regardless of where motorcycles travel in adjacent lanes.
Click to contact our personal injury lawyers today
How Insurance Companies Try to Inflate Motorcyclist Fault
Insurance adjusters employ specific tactics to shift greater fault onto motorcyclists and reduce claim payouts. Recognizing these tactics helps you avoid falling into traps that hurt your compensation.
The Biker Bias Problem
In many claims, Insurance adjusters approach motorcycle accident investigations with assumptions about rider behavior. They may assume motorcyclists were speeding, riding aggressively, or showing off regardless of actual evidence. This prejudice affects how they investigate accidents and assign fault.
Adjusters sometimes point to legal motorcycle modifications like exhaust systems or performance parts as evidence of reckless riding. They may reference motorcycle culture stereotypes to suggest irresponsible behavior. These bias-driven fault assessments ignore the actual evidence showing what caused the collision.
Using Minor Violations to Shift Majority Blame
Insurance companies sometimes cite minor traffic violations to assign majority fault when the other driver committed more serious violations. A motorcyclist following too closely might receive 60% fault, while the driver who stopped suddenly without signaling receives only 40% fault in the insurer’s assessment.
This tactic reverses the actual causation analysis. The minor violation contributed to the accident but did not cause it, while the major violation caused the collision. Proper fault apportionment assigns a greater percentage to the party whose violation played the larger causal role.
We challenge these reversed fault assessments by demonstrating how the other driver’s violations created the dangerous situation that led to the collision. Traffic citations are one piece of evidence, but civil fault is decided under negligence standards and may differ from what a citation suggests.
Recorded Statement Traps
Insurance adjusters request recorded statements shortly after accidents when riders feel shaken and uncertain. Adjusters ask seemingly innocent questions to extract admissions about minor errors like speed, following distance, or attention level.
Riders who honestly acknowledge going slightly over the limit or following somewhat closely give adjusters ammunition to push fault percentages higher. These recorded admissions are used against you during settlement negotiations and in court if cases go to trial.
Third-party insurers cannot require a recorded statement from you, and we advise against giving one without counsel. Your own insurer may require cooperation under your policy terms. Talk to us before you speak to any insurance company about fault-related details.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
What to Do If You Share Fault in Your Charleston Motorcycle Accident
Taking the right steps after an accident where you share some responsibility protects your ability to recover fair compensation despite partial fault.
Don’t Accept the Insurance Company’s Fault Determination
Insurance adjusters present fault assessments as final determinations when they’re actually opening negotiating positions. The adjuster who tells you “our investigation shows you were 60% at fault” makes an argument, not a ruling.
You maintain the right to challenge any fault percentage through negotiation or litigation. Juries determine fault percentages in trials based on evidence presented by both sides. Never agree to a fault percentage assignment during initial conversations with adjusters.
Gather Evidence That Shows the Other Driver’s Greater Negligence
Evidence collection focuses on proving that the other driver’s violations contributed more significantly to the accident than your minor errors. Critical evidence includes:
- Police reports from the Charleston Police Department or South Carolina Highway Patrol Troop 6
- Witness statements describing the other driver’s actions before the collision
- Traffic camera footage from intersections along US-17, Meeting Street, and other Charleston corridors
- Photographs of accident scenes, vehicle damage, skid marks, and road conditions
- Medical records documenting injury severity
The sooner you begin collecting evidence, the stronger your position in challenging inflated fault percentages. Skid marks fade, witnesses forget details, and surveillance footage gets recorded over.
When to Hire a Charleston Motorcycle Accident Lawyer
Hire an attorney immediately when insurance companies assign you substantial fault percentages, especially approaching or exceeding 50%. The stakes are too high to negotiate alone when you’re facing the 51% bar that eliminates all recovery.
Legal representation helps when you have already given a recorded statement admitting some responsibility, received a traffic citation after the accident that the insurer emphasizes, or face pressure to accept a low settlement based on “shared fault” claims.
The Thumbs Up Guys offer free consultations to honestly assess how your actions affect your claim. We’ve recovered compensation for many Charleston riders who shared fault by proving the other driver’s violations played the greater causal role.
How The Thumbs Up Guys Challenge Inflated Fault Percentages
Our approach to comparative fault cases combines thorough investigation with aggressive negotiation and trial preparation. We use sight-line analysis at Charleston intersections to show what each driver could see before the collision. We work with accident reconstruction experts who examine debris field patterns, impact angles, and vehicle crush damage to determine speeds and movements.
We analyze traffic signal timing and phasing at locations like Meeting Street and Highway 17 to prove which party entered the intersection unlawfully. We obtain telematics data when available from vehicles equipped with event data recorders.
We gather medical records from MUSC Health University Medical Center, Roper Hospital, Trident Medical Center, and other Charleston facilities that document injury severity. Serious injuries support arguments that the other driver’s negligence caused high-force impacts.
When insurance companies refuse to assign the appropriate fault to the other driver, we prepare cases for trial. Our track record of recovering millions for injured clients motivates insurance companies to make better settlement offers. Results depend on the facts and are not guaranteed.
FAQ for Partial Fault Motorcycle Accidents
Can I Get Compensation If I Was Speeding During My Charleston Motorcycle Accident?
You may recover compensation even if you were speeding, as long as the other driver bears greater fault. South Carolina’s modified comparative negligence law allows recovery when you’re 50% or less responsible. A small speed variance may contribute a smaller share of fault when the other driver committed serious violations like failing to yield or running a red light. The Thumbs Up Guys present evidence showing how the other driver’s actions caused the collision.
What If I Got a Traffic Citation After My Motorcycle Accident?
Traffic citations are one piece of evidence, but they don’t determine civil liability in accident claims. Police officers make quick fault assessments at accident scenes based on limited information. Courts allow juries to assign different fault percentages than police citations suggest because civil negligence standards differ from traffic violations. We challenge citation-based fault assessments with evidence showing the other driver’s violations contributed more significantly.
Should I Admit Fault to the Insurance Company?
Never admit fault or assign yourself a fault percentage when speaking with insurance adjusters. Admissions hurt your negotiating position and may be used against you throughout the claims process. Provide basic accident facts about location, time, and parties involved, but avoid answering questions about speed, following distance, or fault opinions. We advise clients not to give recorded statements to third-party insurers without preparation and legal guidance.
How Do Attorneys Prove the Other Driver Was More at Fault?
Attorneys prove greater fault through evidence collection and expert analysis. We obtain police reports, witness statements, and traffic camera footage showing the other driver’s violations. We work with accident reconstruction experts who analyze physical evidence to demonstrate causation. We challenge insurance company estimates about speed, visibility, and reaction time with objective data. This evidence shows insurance companies that the other driver bears the majority of the responsibility, despite your minor contributing errors.
Challenge Fault Percentages With The Thumbs Up Guys
Sharing fault for your Charleston motorcycle accident doesn’t mean you lose your right to compensation. South Carolina law protects riders who were 50% or less responsible by allowing reduced recovery based on fault percentages.
Insurance companies may attempt to increase motorcyclist fault percentages to reduce payouts or eliminate liability entirely. The Thumbs Up Guys challenge these tactics with evidence showing the other driver bears greater responsibility.
Call The Thumbs Up Guys at (843) 749-8505 to reach our Charleston office and schedule your free consultation. We provide honest assessments of how your actions affect your claim and work to minimize fault percentages assigned to you. You pay nothing upfront while we pursue fair compensation. Don’t let insurance companies assign you majority fault unfairly— contact us today to protect your rights.
Call or text (843) 380-8350 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form
