Quick Answer
Dog bite claims in South Carolina don’t work like a typical car accident or slip and fall case. Under S.C. Code § 47-3-110, owners are strictly liable for a bite regardless of the dog’s history, but that same statute opens the door to breed-based insurance denials that don’t exist in most other injury claims. Add in the fact that dog bites are one of the few personal injury categories where reconstructive and scar revision surgery is often part of the treatment plan from day one, and it’s clear why these cases need a different playbook than a car accident or slip and fall.
How Is a Dog Bite Claim Different From a Car Accident or Slip and Fall Case?
Most personal injury claims in South Carolina run on a negligence standard. To win a car accident or premises liability case, the injured person generally has to show the other party was careless, whether that’s a driver running a red light or a store failing to clean up a spill. That means proving what the at-fault party knew or should have known before the injury happened.
Dog bites skip that step entirely. South Carolina’s dog bite statute, S.C. Code § 47-3-110, makes an owner strictly liable when their dog bites or otherwise attacks someone who is in a public place or lawfully on private property. It doesn’t matter whether the dog has ever shown aggression before. A dog that has never so much as growled at a stranger can still trigger full liability the first time it bites someone. That single difference changes how these cases are built from the very first phone call.
Where dog bite claims still overlap with other injury cases is on the defense side. Insurance companies and dog owners can raise provocation or trespassing to try to avoid liability under the statute, and South Carolina’s modified comparative negligence rule under S.C. Code § 15-38-15 means they’ll look for any way to argue the victim contributed to the attack. That’s exactly why it matters to have an attorney build the case early, before an insurer gets the chance to spin a normal, instinctive reaction into “provocation.”
For a free legal consultation, call (843) 380-8350
Why Does Insurance Coverage Get Complicated in Dog Bite Cases?
In a typical car accident, the at-fault driver’s auto policy is expected to respond.In a dog bite case, whether insurance will cover the claim at all is often the first question, and it’s one that’s specific to this type of injury.
Most dog bite claims are paid through the owner’s homeowners or renters insurance policy rather than out of pocket. But many insurers maintain breed restriction lists that exclude liability coverage for dogs considered higher risk, commonly including pit bull-type dogs, Rottweilers, German Shepherds, Doberman Pinschers, Chow Chows, Akitas, and a handful of other breeds. Some carriers go further and decline to write a homeowners policy at all if one of these breeds lives in the home. Others will insure the home but attach an endorsement that specifically excludes dog bite liability, or require the owner to sign a liability waiver before extending coverage.
This creates a coverage gap that simply doesn’t exist in a car wreck case. If a breed exclusion applies, the injured person may be left pursuing the dog owner’s personal assets directly rather than an insurance payout, which changes the entire strategy around settlement, negotiation, and what a case is realistically worth. It’s also why documenting the homeowner’s actual policy early, including any riders or endorsements tied to the dog, is one of the first steps in building a dog bite claim.
Why Do Dog Bite Injuries So Often Involve Scar Revision Surgery?
Ask someone what a “personal injury case” looks like and they’ll usually picture broken bones, whiplash, or a herniated disc. Dog bites are different because the injury itself is frequently on the face, hands, or arms, the parts of the body people instinctively use to protect themselves or that sit at a dog’s bite height, especially for children.
That location matters. A wound that would be a minor scar on a thigh becomes a permanent, visible mark on a cheek, lip, or forearm. Because of that, scar revision surgery, laser treatment, and other reconstructive procedures show up in dog bite treatment plans far more often than in most other injury categories. These aren’t cosmetic extras. When a treating physician recommends revision surgery to reduce scarring, the projected cost of that care, including procedures that may not happen for months or years after the attack, becomes part of the damages in the claim.
South Carolina law treats scarring and disfigurement as compensable non-economic damages, and courts and insurance adjusters alike tend to value facial and highly visible scarring more heavily than a comparable injury in a less visible location. That means the timeline of a dog bite case often looks different too. Settling too early, before a plastic surgeon has weighed in on whether revision surgery is likely, can leave money on the table.
Click to contact our personal injury lawyers today
What Should Someone Do Differently After a Dog Bite Compared to Another Injury?
- Identify the dog’s breed and the homeowner’s insurer early. This determines whether a breed exclusion is even a possibility in the claim.
- Get a plastic surgery or dermatology consultation, not just urgent care follow-up, especially for facial or hand injuries, so any recommendation for scar revision is documented.
- Preserve evidence of the attack circumstances, since provocation and trespassing defenses are unique to dog bite claims and don’t come up in most other injury cases.
- Don’t assume the three-year statute of limitations under S.C. Code § 15-3-530 is the only deadline that matters. Insurance-side breed exclusions and coverage disputes can take time to sort out, and that clock is separate from any policy-specific reporting requirements.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
Key Takeaways
- South Carolina holds dog owners strictly liable under § 47-3-110, unlike the negligence standard used in car accident and slip and fall cases.
- Homeowners and renters insurance may exclude coverage for certain breeds, which can leave a victim pursuing the owner directly instead of an insurance payout.
- Dog bites frequently involve facial, hand, or arm injuries that call for scar revision surgery, and that anticipated care should factor into what a claim is worth.
- Comparative negligence, provocation, and trespassing defenses still apply, so the circumstances of the attack matter just as much as the injury itself.
If a dog attack has left you dealing with a denied insurance claim or a scar that needs ongoing treatment, a dog bite attorney at The Thumbs Up Guys can walk through what your case is worth and who’s actually on the hook for it. Click here for a free case review.
Call or text (843) 380-8350 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form
